Blackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554) vs Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle

Head-to-head spec comparison to help you pick the right grill for your needs.

Blackstone

$461.75

Buy on Amazon
vs

Weber

No current Amazon offer

Amazon offer withheld pending exact-model verification.

Verdict

It's a Tie

The Blackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554) and Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle are evenly matched — your choice depends on which features matter most to you.

Spec-by-Spec Comparison

SpecBlackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554)Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle
FuelPropanePropane
Primary cooking area720 sq in756 sq in
Total cooking area720 sq in756 sq in
Burners44
Total BTU60000 BTU48000 BTU
Grate materialRolled carbon steel (7-gauge)Rust-resistant carbon steel
Hopper capacityN/AN/A
Temperature rangeN/A500+ max °F
Dimensions (W×D×H)62.5 x 22 x 36 in77 x 26.4 x 39.5 (lid closed) in
Weight120 lb198 lb
Warranty1 years5 years
Price$461.75No current Amazon offer
Rating8.4/108.2/10
Buy on AmazonAmazon offer withheld pending exact-model verification.

Pros & Cons

Blackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554)

Pros

  • The 36-inch flat-top that built the backyard griddle category
  • 720 sq in of rolled 7-gauge carbon steel
  • Four burners at 60,000 BTU — real zone control
  • Foldable legs on a 120 lb station

Cons

  • 1-year warranty — the weakest we track alongside Royal Gourmet
  • Carbon steel needs seasoning and rust care
  • No lid — it's an open cooktop

Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle

Pros

  • Rust-resistant carbon-steel cooktop — addresses the classic griddle complaint
  • 756 sq in — the largest single cooking surface in this catalog
  • Four burners at 48,000 BTU, reaches over 500°F
  • 5-year limited warranty

Cons

  • $698 is premium griddle money
  • 198 lb assembled — a fixture, not a portable
  • Weber's griddle line is newer than Blackstone's, with a shorter track record

Our Verdicts

Blackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554)

The 1554 is the original 36-inch Blackstone: 720 square inches of carbon steel, four 15,000-BTU burners, and the rear grease system that made flat-top a backyard category. Budget for a cover and seasoning supplies — the 1-year warranty is the weakest we track.

Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle

This page preserves the intended Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle model. The current Amazon offer does not establish that exact identity and variant, so buying links, listing imagery and offer prices are withheld pending verification.

Blackstone Original 36-Inch 4-Burner Griddle (1554)

$461.75

Buy on Amazon

Weber Slate 36-Inch Rust-Resistant Griddle

No current Amazon offer

Amazon offer withheld pending exact-model verification.